I first became interested in health some 20 years ago. I was expecting my daughter at the time and devoured information on diet and nutrition so I could have the "healthiest baby ever." Looking back I see how clueless I was, but at the time I thought I was doing great :)
Over the years I've studied and subscribed to many, many different "healthy" ways of eating. I've done programs like Weight Watchers, Jenny Craig, Nutrisystem and the like, succumbed to the lure of tabloid fads, been in the Zone, hopped on the Atkins train, gone the macrobiotic route, ate for my blood type, ate according to my doshas, sacrificed my carnivorous ways on the altar of vegetarianism, went raw vegan for a while, and plenty of other things I can't remember. And now I'm paleo, which at this stage of the game, feels right to me.
But what about the science behind it? Not just paleo living but all those other dietary plans I've tried over the years. I mean I'm an intelligent person - would I really jump on board if the science behind these things wasn't sound? And given the fact that there are so many different "right" ways to eat, how can the science support them all?
It's been my experience that in life this saying holds true:
You can always find evidence to support whatever you believe.
I don't remember where I first heard that, but it's served me well. Any time someone starts espousing a belief that is vastly different than my own (whether it's healthy related or otherwise) and insisting that their way is the
right way, I simply smile to myself and repeat that saying.
Now don't get me wrong. I am way more open minded than most, and I love considering new theories and expanding my understanding. But when someone starts telling me they're right and I'm wrong, or that they don't believe this or that when I'm pretty sure they haven't taken the time to consider it well - they lose credibility fast.
So what does this have to do with healthy living?
It's been my experience that once a person decides that "this is the right way," they stop looking for alternatives and instead focus on evidence that supports their conclusions.
So a doctor who believes that vegetarian eating is best will focus on studies and data supporting that, largely ignoring things that lead to the opposite conclusion. He'll take successes of patients who do well on this type of program as evidence that it works, and ignore the failures. And this makes sense too. Obviously the patients who are benefiting from his program will stick with it while those who don't will drift away to find something else. So in his own office the patient results will be skewed toward success.
Additionally, he'll most likely read articles that support his theories, and may not even notice the ones that don't. And he'll be interested in studies that support his work too, again ignoring those that don't.
In short he'll surround himself with evidence that his way is the
right way, and every additional piece of information he collects will serve to confirm that. Then of course when he writes his book - well it's going to be a very well written and researched work that solidly "proves" his plan is the best one.
Do you see the problem here? This doctor believes what he's doing is right. He's researched it. He's taught it. He's had results. And now he's publishing a book that will be taken by many as fact. But what he's missing is that the entire thing is skewed based on his narrow minded view of health. It can't possibly be objective.
And that's one reason I don't buy into most of what the experts have to say. I know how human nature is and I know that while they may believe it to be true - that belief may well be based on incomplete data and faulty conclusions.
So if I don't trust the experts, who do I trust?
Basically myself. Yeah I do the research and try to sort out the facts from opinions. And I take everything with a grain of salt because I know that people aren't objective.
And over the years I've developed an eating plan that works for me. How do I know it works?
Well because I feel great, I'm slowly losing weight, people tell me I haven't looked so good in years, many of the health issues I used to have are gone... and did I say I feel great?
The bottom line is that if it improves my health and quality of life than it's the right plan for me. And right now that's paleo.
But - and this is a big BUT - if this ever stops working I'm off the train. I know that my body is constantly changing and what I need 10 years from now may be different than what I need today. That's why I keep an open mind, am willing to consider alternatives, and make a point to keep exploring new possibilities. It can only keep getting better and better :-)